The answer is “not all that long ago”
The very interesting Poverty Analysis blog points me to this graph and argument by Martin Ravallion (which I had missed):
From Ravallion writing on the CGD blog:
today’s rich countries had poverty rates in the early and mid-19th century that are comparable to those found in even relatively poor developing countries today.
…In most cases, their poverty rates fell dramatically in the 19th century (Japan was a late starter but caught up in the 20th century). Yet today there is virtually no extreme poverty left in today’s rich world, when judged by the standards of poor countries today.
when progress against poverty is measured as a % point per year it slowed down a lot toward the end (as can be seen in Figure 1).
More surprisingly, when measured in proportionate terms, experiences differed greatly… Some countries (the US, the UK, Japan) saw steady progress in proportionate terms, while others saw more erratic changes in rates of progress at low poverty rates.
While we often assume that it will be a long hard slog to get the last few percentiles out of extreme poverty, some rich countries maintained steady progress to the end, and some even accelerated.
My favorite, probably embellished, way of making the same point (rich countries recently had horrendous poverty) comes from George Orwell’s Down and Out in Paris and London. A great, great book.
Other equally interesting data and bits at the Poverty Analysis blog.
56 Responses
When did extreme #poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/nPPHBe8Vwg #povertystats #globaldev http://t.co/2eH8ykoqT4
RT @TimHarford: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/aUzJkm3rVU
some perspective on poverty eradication: “When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”?” http://t.co/KRMcdHT2Pd
RT @Actuarialeye: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/DT03L26tsR
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K
When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/DT03L26tsR
When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/pQXoTLGA9f
@KayHymowitz @cblatts New Evidence That Half of the US Is Broke http://t.co/E2RTWoM3Ej via @buzzflash
Has it? RT @TimHarford: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/YGhJVneUxp
“today there is virtually no extreme poverty left in today’s rich world” http://t.co/JGduXQcYdV
RT @JBorgstam: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? The answer is “not all that long ago” http://t.co/rS9lrog8Tz
Chris Blattman: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/3rvCDSgbev
When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? The answer is “not all that long ago” http://t.co/rS9lrog8Tz
When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/vKekjFOu8K
RT @MarkThoma: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? – Chris Blattman http://t.co/N2jkQSvDLX
RT @KayHymowitz: “there is virtually no extreme poverty in today’s rich world, when judged by the standards of poor countries” http://t.co/…
“When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”?” http://t.co/zbxMpDOwdI
Valid point often forgotten “@TimHarford: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/e4T4ZEsWZq“
RT @TimHarford: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/aUzJkm3rVU
When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/9FSvWSUjuR
RT @TimHarford: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/UDsmDWlsfc
“there is virtually no extreme poverty in today’s rich world, when judged by the standards of poor countries” http://t.co/QyIDCmqotN
RT @TimHarford: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/aUzJkm3rVU
RT @TimHarford: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/hWVtt7CusH
RT @TimHarford: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/aUzJkm3rVU
When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”?: The answer is “not all that long ago” The very interest… http://t.co/X92vkqOTgS
RT @TimHarford: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/aUzJkm3rVU
When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/aUzJkm3rVU
When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/IqOvGIbcMA
RT @RachelStrohm: Extreme poverty didn’t end all that long ago in the global North: http://t.co/ShXyJ7kScI (via @cblatts)
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K
“When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”?” http://t.co/dZmrLblsyh
RT @NamiCAGAN: Günümüzün “zengin dünyası”nda yoksulluk ne zaman sona erdi? http://t.co/P5qlbVp80f … http://t.co/lxbfiCpMrk
@cblatts … and George Orwell, was a really skilled writer and I take lessons from him on how to write well.
Extreme poverty didn’t end all that long ago in the global North: http://t.co/ShXyJ7kScI (via @cblatts)
RT @NamiCAGAN: Günümüzün “zengin dünyası”nda yoksulluk ne zaman sona erdi? http://t.co/P5qlbVp80f … http://t.co/lxbfiCpMrk
Günümüzün “zengin dünyası”nda yoksulluk ne zaman sona erdi? http://t.co/P5qlbVp80f … http://t.co/lxbfiCpMrk
RT @segerfeldt: När utrotades den extrema fattigdomen i dagens rika länder? Mkt intressant. Notera hur vi släpade efter…. http://t.co/I5D…
RT @MarkThoma: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? – Chris Blattman http://t.co/N2jkQSvDLX
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K
RT @segerfeldt: När utrotades den extrema fattigdomen i dagens rika länder? Mkt intressant. Notera hur vi släpade efter…. http://t.co/I5D…
RT @MarkThoma: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? – Chris Blattman http://t.co/N2jkQSvDLX
When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? – Chris Blattman
@Chloe_Crain @ArzagaGenius @denis_swagner http://t.co/Ei7rYK8GiL
RT @MarkThoma: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? – Chris Blattman http://t.co/N2jkQSvDLX
When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? – Chris Blattman http://t.co/N2jkQSvDLX
RT @segerfeldt: När utrotades den extrema fattigdomen i dagens rika länder? Mkt intressant. Notera hur vi släpade efter…. http://t.co/I5D…
RT @segerfeldt: När utrotades den extrema fattigdomen i dagens rika länder? Mkt intressant. Notera hur vi släpade efter…. http://t.co/I5D…
När utrotades den extrema fattigdomen i dagens rika länder? Mkt intressant. Notera hur vi släpade efter…. http://t.co/I5DFRTZNn6
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K
RT @cblatts: When did extreme poverty end in today’s “rich world”? http://t.co/n0W1burh6K