Short answer: For any given water molecule, the odds are basically negligible. But the odds that you’ve drank at least one water molecule twice are pretty much 100%.
Long answer: Think in terms of the numbers of water molecules on earth. In a cup of water there are about 1024 water molecules (100 g / 18 amu ~ 1024).
The total mass of water on earth is approximately 1024 g of water, which works out to about 1046 water molecules on earth.
So if you pick 1024 molecules out of 1046, put them back into the 1046 and mix them back up, and randomly choose another 1024, what are the odds you’ll pick at least one atom twice? We can approximate it in the same way we do the birthday problem: P = 1-e-n2 /2m where n=1024 and m=1046. Turns out this number is basically equal to 1, so the odds are almost certain that any two glasses of water will have at least one atom in common. This generalizes between every cup of water – in that cup of coffee you’re sipping right now, the odds are good that it has shared atoms with basically every person to ever live.
66 Responses
Long answer: Think in terms of the numbers of water molecules on earth. In a cup of water there are about 1024 water molecules (100 g / 18 amu ~ 1024).
golu dolls
golu dolls
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
There are some objections in the comments https://t.co/AbgvzMq31E
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
@chrisjkam @cblatts not sure how I feel about this sort of thing… https://t.co/AoxKF6PpK1
@cblatts that is interesting!
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/vZ7YKKzqO0 #birthdayproblem #probability #water
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @CafeEconomics: Annals of probability …
https://t.co/4TSjcOq34r
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/BjZ66yHKnC LT @CafeEconomics
@bill_easterly @cblatts Better call Taleb. @nntaleb
What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/BhB8wpEcKS
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @CafeEconomics: Annals of probability …
https://t.co/4TSjcOq34r
Annals of probability …
https://t.co/4TSjcOq34r
What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/CpxRqZeIdk
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
Mind explosion: https://t.co/pA5fiyAxdv
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
@cblatts @tylercowen can’t possibly compete with the @xkcdComic analysis that “every water molecule has been part of a dinosaur.”
“in that cup of coffee you’re sipping right now, odds are good that it shared atoms with every person to ever live” https://t.co/xxSry3yYql
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
RT @bill_easterly: Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov4…
Beauty of probability — you have almost certainly drunk the same water molecule twice. By @cblatts https://t.co/3HrAov418T
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/8c5mnLJoum #favoritosde salvador leal #feedly
What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/IWxODYGwm6 #mccdecon #econcsustan #econmjc
@cblatts @tylercowen
Cool analysis, but surely wrong…
“Life cycle” of that cup of water not random
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
@Mjreard @cblatts and glaciers/ice sheets can store water 10 times that long.
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
@Mjreard @cblatts Thermohaline circulation can have residency times of 1000s of years. So… probably not 100% https://t.co/4zZZiyZPlD
Really important Hydrology problem: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/zbEPx5iz1x
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
@cblatts water is not randomly distributed; I think this has an especially big effect for the every cup -> every human ever claim, no?
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
The chance you’ve drank the same molecule of water twice are the same as LeBron NOT driving a Kia.
About 100%. https://t.co/MH6CNvGeXw
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo
Heraclitus says “My sources say no” #SameRiverTwice #SharedAtoms https://t.co/lv2th5dIjZ @cblatts
RT @cblatts: What’s the chance you have drunk the same water molecule twice? https://t.co/eAVbPI9bdo