Is a goat given the same as a goat earned?

The West Coast’s most infamous group of African political economists meets this week, and I have to miss the meeting due to my easterly movement of late. The papers, available here, include some superb economics and political science job market papers.

Of special note, Pamela Jakiela introduces experimental economics to western Kenya and finds a different set of preferences than in the US for rewarding hard work and helpful actions and punishing uncooperative ones.

Underlying her experiments are potential differences in how people feel obligated to share money earned versus money given, and conversely, how others in your playing group conceive of your obligation to share money won versus money earned.

The cross-cultural differences in such norms are a potentially important determinant of development. Social norms of reciprocity that helped insure individuals against bad crops and other shocks in pre-industrial times are slow to change, and could inhibit the development of industry to the extent that individual capital accumulation becomes more difficult. (This is an important hypothesis waiting to be explored.)

The difference between money earned versus money given has another important application in humanitarian and development aid. Last week I was speaking with a woman heading the Norwegian Refugee Council’s development work in northern Uganda. She’s having much more difficulty than she expected helping to restock the all-but depleted livestock in northern Uganda.
Pastoral livelihoods were essential in pre-war Acholiland, and NRC has been giving the poorest young men and women goats to begin breeding and selling. Likewise, a government program has been providing tens of thousands of cattle, pigs and goats across the north to vulnerable groups of people.

Apparently, however, people have been taking very poor care of these given goats. This could reflect a lack of skills and experience in livestock-rearing (the most popular explanation), but people have only been displaced for four years, and I have a hard time believing that they’ve forgotten how to care for a goat. Even this city boy knows the basics.

I think it would be interesting to look at the difference between a goat given and a goat earned. This would be a fairly straightforward development project to set up experimentally. The results speaks to a much larger debate about the way humanitarian and development aid is designed. This is definitely an idea to follow up with NRC, and a way to finally coax Pam into abandoning Busia and coming to work on northern Uganda.

The potential paper titles alone make the idea worthwhile.

2 thoughts on “Is a goat given the same as a goat earned?

  1. Hi, My name is fred wilson and i just want to share my experience with everyone.
    I have being hearing about this blank ATM card for a while and i never really
    paid any interest to it because of my doubts. Until one day i discovered a financial
    group called micro finance group while i was searching for job online.
    They are really good at what they re doing.

    Back to the point, I inquired about The Blank ATM Card. If it works or even Exist.
    They told me Yes and that its a card programmed for random money withdraws without
    being noticed also has a technique that makes it impossible for the CCTVs to detect
    you can also be used for free online purchases of any kind. This was shocking
    and i still had my doubts. Then i gave it a try and asked for the card and agreed to their terms and conditions. Hoping and praying it was not a scam.
    three days later i received my card and tried with the closest ATM machine close to me
    It worked like magic. I was able to withdraw up to $3000. This was unbelievable and the happiest day of my life. So far i have being able to withdraw up to $35000 without any stress of being caught. I don’t know why i am posting this here, i just felt this might help those of us in need of financial stability. BLANK ATM CARD FIRM has really change my life. If you want to contact them, Here is the email address [email protected].
    And I believe they will also Change your Life too. Contact their general manager directly with the above email address.