Presenting data on all full-length articles published in the three top general economics journals for one year in each of the 1960s through 2010s, I analyze how patterns of co-authorship, age structure and methodology have changed, and what the possible causes of these changes may have been.
A new paper by Daniel Hammermesh. He examines the QJE, AER and JPE.
Especially interesting is the changing number of authors (production function?):
Authors are getting older. And now just 87.4% male dominated instead of 95.3%!
And apparently we are getting more empirical but less likely to use existing data (in spite of the Internet!).
60 Responses
this is interesting! is the implication that field work is becoming sexier, that there is a publishing bias toward having ‘new’ and ‘your own’ data, that field experiments are fun because the data collection is potentially harder but the analysis is potentially more straightforward… or that ‘standard’ datasets like DHS and LSMS (at least for dev econ) need an update to be more useful for the types of questions people want to ask now? presumably, the move towards empirical field work and the decline of the use of theory are linked phenomena?
RT @HiddenBrain Wow, equality by 2400! MT @diane1859 & @cblatts #Economics articles 95.3% in 1963. Now 87.4% http://t.co/ArEvwr6W … #sexism
Wow, equality by 2400! MT @diane1859 & @cblatts #Economics articles 95.3% in 1963. Now 87.4% http://t.co/Wwb6HEaO #sexism
Proportion theory papers in AER/QJE/JPE: 1963: 50.7%. 2011: 19.1%. http://t.co/v2SQMwe8
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/8jXl37RHÂ … (HT @davdittrich)
Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/AMZ7JxKi via @zite
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/YyDbaGlr (HT @davdittrich)
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/YyDbaGlr (HT @davdittrich)
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/YyDbaGlr (HT @davdittrich)
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/YyDbaGlr (HT @davdittrich)
RT @dancohen: In 1963, 84% of articles in top economics journals were single-authored; in 2011, 20%. http://t.co/LyCHD0zp (via Marginal Revolution)
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/YyDbaGlr (HT @davdittrich)
RT @dancohen: In 1963, 84% of articles in top economics journals were single-authored; in 2011, 20%. http://t.co/LyCHD0zp (via Marginal Revolution)
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/YyDbaGlr (HT @davdittrich)
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/YyDbaGlr (HT @davdittrich)
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/YyDbaGlr (HT @davdittrich)
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/YyDbaGlr (HT @davdittrich)
RT @diane1859: Economics journal articles now only 87.4% male, down from 95.3% in 1963! http://t.co/YyDbaGlr (HT @davdittrich)
Six decades of economics publishing | Chris Blattman http://t.co/JS5TM49I
@Lcimedia Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/n2IfF8CN
RT @freakonometrics: “Six decades of economics publishing” (in QJE, AER and JPE) https://t.co/d3GCnn74 via @cblatts’s http://t.co/kstkJbcs http://t.co/GdZsDWku
RT @freakonometrics: “Six decades of economics publishing” (in QJE, AER and JPE) https://t.co/d3GCnn74 via @cblatts’s http://t.co/kstkJbcs http://t.co/GdZsDWku
“Six decades of economics publishing” (in QJE, AER and JPE) https://t.co/d3GCnn74 via @cblatts’s http://t.co/kstkJbcs http://t.co/GdZsDWku
RT @MarkThoma: Six decades of economics publishing – Chris Blattman http://t.co/EqK3034X
RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/BVcbNidG
RT @MarkThoma: Six decades of economics publishing – Chris Blattman http://t.co/EqK3034X
Trends in economics publishing: Noticeable decline in theory http://t.co/JislDuBk
RT @MarkThoma: Six decades of economics publishing – Chris Blattman http://t.co/EqK3034X
RT @MarkThoma: Six decades of economics publishing – Chris Blattman http://t.co/EqK3034X
Six decades of economics publishing – Chris Blattman http://t.co/EqK3034X
RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/BVcbNidG
RT @dancohen: In 1963, 84% of articles in top economics journals were single-authored; in 2011, 20%. http://t.co/LyCHD0zp (via Marginal Revolution)
RT @dancohen: In 1963, 84% of articles in top economics journals were single-authored; in 2011, 20%. http://t.co/LyCHD0zp (via Marginal Revolution)
RT @dancohen: In 1963, 84% of articles in top economics journals were single-authored; in 2011, 20%. http://t.co/LyCHD0zp (via Marginal Revolution)
In 1963, 84% of articles in top economics journals were single-authored; in 2011, 20%. http://t.co/LyCHD0zp (via Marginal Revolution)
Data on the last sixty years of economics publishing trends: http://t.co/pxypzwQ9
RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/BVcbNidG
RT @fravel: Noticeable decline in theory RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/u4ZraA1H
Noticeable decline in theory RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/u4ZraA1H
RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/BVcbNidG
RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/BVcbNidG
But Chris, you look so young! RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/yyGLUzS0
RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/BVcbNidG
RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/BVcbNidG
RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/BVcbNidG
RT @cblatts: Six decades of economics publishing http://t.co/BVcbNidG